Customer leaves ‘negative tip’ as shift end calls for waitress switcheroo: Reddit debates validity, ‘Jokes on them…’

Reddit users jumped into an uproarious debate after seeing a viral post suggest a customer left a “negative tip” when their server switched out with another after the former's shift ended. The post shared a glimpse at the check's “customer copy,” offering visual proof that they were supposed to pay a total amount of $69.54. However, dissatisfied with the dining experience, the customer seemingly called out their server for having their co-worker take over for them without informing the diner. The original post is captioned: “My coworker’s shift ended so I took over one of their tables. Customer did not like this and left a negative tip.”

This supposedly rubbed the customer the wrong way. Expressing their qualms with the employee, they made serious claims on the check, subtracting a minimal amount of their total, apparently listing it as a “negative tip.” The customer copy shows them work out the math, as they wrote “-3.50” against the “+tip” marking on the check, bringing the total to $66.04.

The diner also appeared to have left a brief review of their experience at the undisclosed restaurant in flawed English. “Servies want not good Watriss changed without notifying us,” they wrote on the check.

Also read | OpenAI CEO Sam Altman's $27m mansion with ‘Batcave’ is a leaky ‘lemon,’ lawsuit says

Reddit responds to supposed “negative tip”

The supposed “negative” transaction had Reddit users raving about whether it was real or fake. While thousands of netizens poked fun at the customer’s written English, others deciphered the impact of the “negative tip.”

According to the National Literacy Institute, 21% of adults in the US were illiterate in 2024, whereas 54% of adults had literacy below a 6th-grade level. The 2024 literacy statistics also revealed that while New Mexico recorded the lowest child literacy rate, California had the lowest adult literacy rate.

Redditors jumped on the bandwagon, quoting these figures to drag the customer in question. “I love the illiterate spelling on the receipt. It goes well with the vibe from the customer,” a user wrote in the post’s comment section. Someone else commented: “Whenever people tell me that ChatGPT can't replace real humans, I think about how many real humans write like this.”

On the other side of the spectrum, users tried their best to fathom the implications of the “negative tip.” A Redditor questioned: “Is this a new life hack for cheaper prices?” Yet another user spat out, “What don’t you guys get? He wrote down a negative tip so now they owe him money, it’s simple.” Seemingly unending conversations around the supposed “Uno Reverse” moment clouded netizens’ judgement.

A Redditor wondered, “Serious question though: what does the restaurant do when someone writes this? I’m assuming they’re still getting charged for the meal and a 0 tip, but still wondering.” Another replied, “Depends on the restaurant. A lot of them charge the amount written for the tip as a tip, so -3.50 is a $3.50 tip for the waiter. Some restaurants just mark it as a zero, and some restaurants perma ban those customers.”

Regardless of where the discussion bent, more and more confusion arose on the forum. Several others argued that “negative cost” was as good as nothing consequential. “Yes. The credit card agreement is that you owe what is listed. You can't just write 'negative cost" and owe nothing. They can dispute with the credit card company, but the credit card company isn't going to entertain this nonsense.”

Also read | Taylor Swift dominates best-selling albums of 2024 in US so far; 3 K-pop acts also in the mix. See top 10

Yet others couldn’t let go of the humour of the situation. “Pro Tip: write down -$5,000,000 and retire,” a user quipped. On the other hand, a different group of Redditors speculated what good it would’ve been to the customer had the former waitress informed them about the impending switcheroo.

While some agreed with the idea that basic courtesy required the server to notify their customer, the blown-out “overreaction” in its omission was vastly unwarranted. “Oh yes because the waiter should stay past their shift just to let you finish your meal

Edit: I get that people have to stay past their shift a lot. For me this was mainly just on closing shifts and my managers preferred we didn’t for other shifts since they’d have to pay until we clocked out. I also usually worked on pooled tips (which has its pros and cons). Everyone has had different experiences.

Edit: yes I agree with everyone who said they should have let the table know, that’s not what I’m saying, I’m saying this was an overreaction,” someone commented."

Another person said, “Aside from the awful spelling, handwriting, and whatever the hell a negative tip means - it is standard practice in the industry to let customers know you are switching primary servers. Misleading headline makes it sound as if OP did nothing wrong here, but this is pretty well established standard practice and a polite courtesy in the service industry."

Some other users who had prior experience working at eateries responded that it was “mandatory” for servers to stay at certain places until the assigned diner finished their meal. Once the servers were compelled to wait for the diner to leave in order to sign off from their duties, the management would even suggest they stay occupied with “more side work,” which was unfair considering their meagre wages or salaries allotted per hour.

Meanwhile, another crowd of users considered that the diner was possibly so petty that the server knew it would be better to desert them. “Something about the loss of 3.50 tells me she knew it wasn’t worth it.”

As the conversation continued endlessly, several others noted the diner had basically mentioned the issue on the customer copy so it made no difference. Meanwhile, some pointed out that a “negative tip” was irrelevant to them paying the full amount. “That’s not how any of this works lol they got charged the full amount.” Someone else responded, “Jokes on them, they’re still paying the full amount. They signed the printed receipt, so they’re legally bound. Dumba**es.”

Another Redditor dug deeper: “For those who don’t know - the full amount has already been charged (credit card was ran and approved already). They can write whatever they want but the restaurant already has its money. They just didn’t tip to be spiteful. If they fight this with the bank, I guarantee that manager will be elated to prove what he owed and paid.”

Yet another user chimed in: “Their card was already swiped so this is just them not leaving a tip. I'm not entirely sure what they thought was gonna happen lol.”

Despite other comments, a group of people were also astounded by the inflated amount of “suggested tip” mentioned on the check. “The fact that the “suggested tip” starts at 18% is the most infuriating.”